Time-keepers error costs McPhilbin British belt

Some things are just too controversial and costly to simply sweep under the carpet and forget about.

And the first-round farce which saw the bell ring to end the session between Nottingham's British cruiserweight champion Shane McPhilbin and Enzo Maccarinelli with 47 seconds remaining is one of those.

In any circumstance it would be bad enough - after all, a round is either three minutes exactly or two minutes exactly, not a second more or a second less.

What's worse is that former WBO world cruiserweight boss Maccarinelli had been dropped heavily and had drunkenly stumbled around when trying to get himself in a vertical position.

With 47 seconds remaining on the clock and with Enzo's eyes swimming and senses scrambled, McPhilbin should have then tore into the challenger and registered a sensational one-round stoppage [or knockout] victory and won those who'd piled money on him at 150/1 massive sums. 

Or not.

Because as soon as referee Ian John-Lewis had deemed the Italian-rooted Welshman fit to continue fighting, the bell rang to end the round. The fighters are too involved in the moment to know when the bell should ring or not; they just carry on fighting until they're separated.

But that decision was disgraceful - and, with all due respect to time-keeper Martin Fallon, he should, because of the costly nature of the error, have his licence revoked by the British Boxing Board of Control and never be allowed to participate at ringside again. 

Mr Fallon's incompetence in that situation is unforgivable, and no amount of apologising will change what happened. An immediate rematch for McPhilbin won't hand him back his British title, which he won in Rocky-like fashion with a come-from-behind 12-round stoppage over Leon Williams in January. 

If you ask me - and this isn't to take away from Enzo's nervy performance after the opening session - a No Contest should be declared; it's the only fair outcome on an error that undoubtedly changed the outcome.story told about this fight.

As for what happened between the ropes during the 12-rounder, most of the action on the Paul Rowson and Frank Warren-promoted bill at Wolverhampton Civic Hall was packed into the first nine minutes, with the ex-European champion [13st 7lbs 10oz] sensationally hitting the deck twice in that period. 

A sweeping left hook sent the notoriously-fragile Maccarinelli, 31, crashing down inside two minutes. His eyes swimming and legs like mounds of stacked jelly, the Swansea-based puncher was ready to go - and never has a bell saved a fighter at the right time, albeit at the wrong time for anyone that wasn't associated with Enzo.

Shane [14st 3lbs] followed up in the second with more booming punches that had a man who'd dominated world-class Wayne Braithwaite in his pomp looking decidedly unsteady. And a left and a grazing right from the well-supported Bullwell banger stuck Enzo down for a second time in the latter stages of the third, though it wasn't as damaging as the first.

The feeling at ringside was that it was only a matter of time before Carl Greaves-handled McPhilbin nailed him with a big punch again, closed matters and headed back to Nottingham with the British title in his case. But that wasn't to  be the case, and i didn't have him winning another round after that, surprisingly.

A round-by-round breakdown would be unnecessary, as it followed in the same messy and frustrating pattern of attempted punching and falling into hold . Enzo, in essence, mauled his way through the remainder and caught McPhilbin, 26, with punches as he came in - parrying the vicious-looking overhand swings that came his way.

The sessions were marred by lots of claiming, but Maccarinelli did score a knockdown in the ninth which, in truth, looked more of a push. Normal business was resumed in the eleventh, however, and though i thought the champion put in a solid effort in the final three minutes, i still scored it level for a 115-111 tally.

My way of scoring was agreed with by Victor Loughlin, with Birmingham's Terry O'Connor marking it 116-111 and Wellingborough's John Keane seeing it 115-110. The scores may have varied but they were unanimous and there was no doubting the winner, whose showing have convinced many that he should hang his gloves up before he suffers another heavy knockout defeat.

Maccarinelli improves to 35-5 (27); McPhilbin, still the Midlands Area champion and surely in line for a rematch or a crack at the vacant title if Enzo, as expected, vacates, drops to 8-3 (5).